Buy or rent a chocolate fountain and have guests dip fruits and cakes in it for a take home treat!
We found an affordable fountain at
cooking.com
(search for chocolate fountain)
Make or buy sugar cookies in cute shapes such as baby bottles, tools, sports shapes, animal, etc.
Candles for the ladies/Cigars for the men - or bubble gum cigars for both
Baby bottles filled with candy (such as pastel jelly bellies) with candy
Have a baby-themed pinata for the guests to hit. Guys love feeling like kids again!
Check out
Oriental Trading
for additional favor ideas! They have really cool pacifier suckers!